Silly Rating : 3.5/5

Site link : http://diabloiiikore.com/

About the site : 

                   My very first impression on this site is Wow!. This site is totally about Diablo related stuff. You can find videos and a loads of stuff related to that. Very useful site for diablo fans. Comics, Diablo Videos, Games are other entertaining stuff. Magazines on Diablo, Books related can be downloaded from this site. Awesome!

Content: 4/5

Lots and lots of content, but its poorly arranged, more on that later. You have to focus on arrangement of your website. You have posted a lot of stuff in your home page. Can you arrange those stuff in a proper manner which helps the user to understand easily how to navigate. Your site is very kool.

Layout: 4/5

Darker than Diablo himself! Ok, maybe not, but you use a lot of black and nothing to offset it. Also your side bar is way too cluttered. Remove the ads and non-navigation stuff to clear it up and easier to use. The vary basic arrangement is the only thing good. But your site is looking great. Main Navigation Menu is too good.

Organization: 2/5

Ok, the basic links are good, but your home page has way to much stuff on it, your other pages need some nav links so you can find specific info from that page, and your sidebar is a random mess. Clean it up a bit and put some quick jump links on your large pages (which is all of them). 

Look and Feel: 3/5

Black, clutters, and over whelming. Clean up the page, add some color, and make it easy to navigate. With that I think it would be a very good site.

Note: Have you thought about adding a forum? It would be great on that kinda site.